Whatever Your Circumstances Are, Help Is Here.

Private disability insurance vs. ERISA plans: pros and cons

On Behalf of | Aug 14, 2023 | ERISA, Long-Term Disability Insurance

Deciding to get long-term disability insurance is like facing a choice between two important job offers. On the one hand, there’s private insurance. This choice offers a customizable package tailored to your unique circumstances. It is like a job role that aligns perfectly with your skills and aspirations. On the other hand, you have ERISA plans. Think of a job with automatic enrollment and group benefits – convenient, but with less room for negotiation.

Just as you would like to weigh the pros and cons of each job offer, making this decision sets the stage for you and your loved ones’ financial security.

Private disability insurance

Private disability insurance offers a broader spectrum of benefits. It supplies policyholders:

  • A tailored coverage
  • More options for benefit amounts, coverage duration and provisions
  • More accommodating evaluation of claims
  • Coverage portability even if you change jobs or leave the workforce temporarily
  • More room for negotiating and appealing claim denials

However, customization and flexibility often come with higher costs, not to mention possible premium hikes over time as you age or if the insurer’s costs rise. Then there is also a potential for stricter medical underwriting and exclusions for preexisting conditions. Insurance companies may also prioritize their financial interests. This may result in the denial of legitimate claims.

ERISA plans

ERISA plans, or Employment Retirement Income Security Act plans, are employee benefit plans regulated by the federal government in the United States. Its main advantage is the convenience of automatic enrollment and potentially lower premiums due to group rates.

Yet, the ERISA framework comes with limitations. Legal recourse if a denied claim is restricted, and claim disputes are more complex, wherein the final decision often rests with the plan administrator.

ERISA plans also have strict administrative procedures and tend to have standardized benefits. So, there is less room for customization.

Whether you opt for the standardized benefits of an ERISA plan or the tailored coverage of private insurance, your choice should reflect your unique circumstances and priorities.

FindLaw Network